Search: A Year in Champagne

Skip to main content

Go to accessibility options

1932-D 25C AU58 NGC. A pleasing near-Mint example of this first year issue, well defined and lustrous, with light champagne-gray toning and a few wispy marks on the portrait of our first president. A trace of wear on the highpoints indicates probable light circulation. The key date to the Washington quarter series. (PCGS# 5791)
Auction 384 | Lot: 2889 | Sep 24, 2005

Sold For: $603.75
1893-S $1 MS64 NGC. This is the highly desired key-date issue that is on nearly every Morgan dollar want list. Just 100,000 business strikes were coined, the lowest mintage of any Morgan dollar issue except the unknown 1895-P with a recorded mintage of just 12,000 coins. There have never been any significant hoards of 1893-S Morgan dollars located, and none were in the Treasury release of the 1960s. In The Morgan and Peace Dollar Text Book, author Wayne Miller mentioned a small hoard: "Many BU 1893-S dollars can be traced to a hoard of twenty pieces found in a BU bag of 1894-S dollars in Great Falls, Montana in the early 1950s. These dollars were dispersed over a twenty year period, one or two at a time." Even the casual numismatic observer is aware of the importance and rarity of this issue, and is likely aware that few Mint State specimens exist. The specialist will want to consider this opportunity that may not be repeated for a very long time. Nearly all survivors from the limited mintage grade in the Very Fine range. Lower grade and higher grade coins are both seen with less frequency. Mint State examples seldom become available to collectors. Don't miss this opportunity.

This Choice Mint State dollar is a borderline prooflike specimen with satiny luster in the fields on both sides. The reverse, if viewed separately, might qualify as prooflike. The obverse has light champagne color with a crescent of lilac, heather, blue, and amber toning above Liberty. The balance of the obverse has wisps of gold confined to the border. The reverse has bluish-silver color without other toning. Both of the tiny die markers on the obverse are clearly visible on this specimen. A tiny die chip is located in the left base of R and a diagonal die line severs the left arm of T. Both of these are characteristics of genuine '93-S Morgans, and are visible on every known example. The die line in T remains visible on all but the most extensively worn examples of this issue. The combined po (PCGS# 7226)
Auction 352 | Lot: 6961 | Aug 21, 2004

Sold For: $198,375.00
1878 7TF $1 Reverse of 1878 PR 63 PCGS. An important first-year proof delivery, this champagne-gray example is pleasingly reflective despite a somewhat hazy toning scheme. If there are any grade-defining hairlines, they are well concealed and not distracting to the naked eye. (PCGS# 7312)
Auction 244 | Lot: 7662 | Jan 6, 2001

Sold For: $2,300.00
1867 5C Rays PR65 Cameo PCGS. This is only the tenth time we have offered an example of this important rarity in any of our sales since 1993. Almost remarkably, it is the third example that we have offered this year! We offered a PR64 PCGS example in our April 2006 CSNS sale and a PR66 Cameo example in our Denver Platinum Night sale last month. It seems that multiple examples offered in a short period of time has happened before. We handled four different examples of this issue between November 2003 and August 2004.

This is an example of John Dannreuther's second striking from his "Obverse 2." As "JD" pointed out: "Although these cannot be conclusively called restrikes, they were struck after the Obverse 1 coins as the reverse is a later state of the same die. The die lineage is obvious when comparing the reverse states. As each new striking occurred, the reverse was polished, possibly to remove rust or just to 'shine' it up for striking. These characteristics are the ones known to Breen and have been used for decades by numismatists ad the definitive identifiers for 1867 With Rays proofs."

In his Complete Encyclopedia, Breen suggested that just 12 to 15 coins are known. The CoinFacts website estimates an original proof mintage of 75 coins. The actual surviving population of proof examples is probably somewhere between these two extremes, probably in the vicinity of 25 to 30 coins. This example is an attractive cameo proof with excellent contrast. The fields are completely mirrored with excellent depth, surrounding fully lustrous devices. Both sides have light nickel-gray color with traces of lilac, blue, and champagne toning. A few tiny specks and minute blemishes are visible on each side, but the overall eye appeal is exceptional. Population: 3 in 65, 4 finer (7/06).
From The Troy Wiseman Collection. (PCGS# 83818)
Auction 416 | Lot: 783 | Sep 16, 2006

Sold For: $69,000.00
1927-D 1C MS65 Red PCGS. Olive-yellow in color with an additional hint of champagne-rose hues. A lustrous Gem with an above average strike and gorgeously preserved surfaces. Population: 47 in 65, 2 finer (9/02).
From the Francis Sullivan Collection. (PCGS# 2581)
Auction 304 | Lot: 5483 | Nov 23, 2002

Sold For: $1,380.00
1876-S 10C Dime MS 65. A moderately frosted gem with light champagne-gray patination. The underlying surfaces are moderately frosted and free of distracting blemishes. Although the mintmark appears as an indistinct blob, the balance of the features are smartly impressed. Common in circulated and lower Mint State grades, this issue is quite scarce at the gem level. From the Litrenta Collection. This lot will first be sold conditionally. After Lots 5511 through 5529 are sold conditionally, they will be offered as a complete set as Lot 5529, starting at 5% over the total of the individual lots. (PCGS# 4681)
Auction 208 | Lot: 5516 | Aug 16, 1999

Sold For: $1,380.00
LEROY NEIMAN (American, b. 1926)
Champagne, New Year's Eve, 2006
Serigraph on paper
24...
Auction 7010 | Lot: 87228 | Jul 15, 2009

Sold For: $1,314.50
1907 $20 Arabic Numerals MS 63. This first-year example has full, bright luster with an adequate strike. Delicate champagne toning overlays select areas of both sides and draws attention away from the scattered contact marks.
From the Joseph J. Abbell Collection of U.S. Gold Coins. (PCGS# 9141)
Auction 213 | Lot: 5721 | Nov 21, 1999

Sold For: $1,265.00
1939-S 50C Oregon MS66 PCGS. An attractive final-year piece that has golden-orange and pale champagne-gray patina on each side. Solidly struck with pleasing luster. (PCGS# 9354)
Auction 430 | Lot: 6098 | Feb 17, 2007

Sold For: $874.00
1892 50C Half Dollar MS 64 ICG. An attractive representative of this popular first-year delivery, the lightly toned, champagne-gray surfaces exhibit a rich endowment of mint frost. Sharply struck with minimal abrasions. (PCGS# 6461)
Auction 232 | Lot: 5286 | Aug 10, 2000

Sold For: $718.75
1916-S 1C MS64 Red PCGS. Yellow-green and champagne-rose colors. A nicely struck near-Gem with moderate luster and well preserved surfaces.
From the Francis Sullivan Collection. (PCGS# 2494)
Auction 304 | Lot: 5423 | Nov 23, 2002

Sold For: $718.75
1837 H10C No Stars MS 62 PCGS. An important first-year example, the surfaces are bathed in original, mottled champagne and electric-blue iridescence. With pinpoint striking detail and minimal abrasions, this coin has the appeal of a significantly higher grade. (PCGS# 4311)
Auction 232 | Lot: 6825 | Aug 10, 2000

Sold For: $546.25
1867 5C No Rays PR63 Cameo PCGS. This second-year proof is lightly tinged in champagne-gray shades that deepen to a milky consistency in a few areas on both sides. (PCGS# 83821)
Auction 372 | Lot: 5892 | May 7, 2005

Sold For: $402.50
1867 5C No Rays PR63 Cameo PCGS. This second-year proof is lightly tinged in champagne-gray shades that deepen to a milky consistency in a few areas on both sides. This coin is one of only two proof 1867 No Rays Nickels certified Cameo by PCGS. (PCGS# 83821)
Auction 293 | Lot: 310 | Jun 9, 2002

Sold For: $391.00
1913-S 5C Type One MS 65. Delicate champagne-apricot iridescence blankets both sides of this lustrous first-year example. With nicely defined features and smooth surfaces, this coin should be of obvious importance to Gem quality type collectors. (PCGS# 3917)
Auction 230 | Lot: 5986 | Jun 13, 2000

Sold For: $368.00
1889 3CN PR65 NGC. This final-year specimen displays mottled golden-champagne iridescence over bright, carefully preserved surfaces. A very tiny planchet flaw (as struck) in the reverse field at the left wreath is noted for accuracy. (PCGS# 3786)
Auction 300 | Lot: 5773 | Sep 28, 2002

Sold For: $345.00
1929 $2 1/2 MS 62 NGC. This final-year example shows pleasing champagne-gold coloration and relatively few abrasions for the grade. (PCGS# 7953)
Auction 228 | Lot: 432 | Jun 7, 2000

Sold For: $218.50
1935-S $1 MS 63 PCGS. Light champagne toning is present on the lustrous surfaces of this moderately abraded final-year S-mint example. (PCGS# 7379)
Auction 232 | Lot: 6451 | Aug 10, 2000

Sold For: $184.00
1899 $1 PR68 Cameo PCGS. Only 330,000 business strike Morgan Dollars were made at Philadelphia during the year, along with an additional 846 Proofs. The low mintage of business strikes has transferred some of the demand for this date to the proofs. This example is an impressive Superb Gem Proof with excellent cameo contrast. The surfaces on both sides are essentially brilliant, with only a trace of champagne toning at the borders. Essentially perfect with only a slight scratch northeast of the final 9 in the date. Population: 1 in 68, 0 finer (11/05).
From The JFS Collection, Part Three. (PCGS# 87334)
Auction 394 | Lot: 3381 | Jan 7, 2006

Sold For: $48,875.00

Make Offer to Owner
$73,312 or more
1889-CC $1 MS63+ PCGS. CAC. After a four year hiatus the Carson City Mint resumed production of the Morgan silver dollars in 1889 to the tune of 350,000 pieces. Heavy circulation combined with rough storage and handling practices combine to rank the 1889-CC among the most famous and desirable issues in the series in Mint State. The 1889-CC becomes conditionally rare at the Select Uncirculated level, and finer pieces become extremely challenging with PCGS showing only three in Gem grades or finer (8/25).

This attractive, Plus-graded Select Uncirculated example exhibits brilliant centers bordered with iridescent shades of caramel, cobalt-blue and plum. The devices are nicely frosted, although some luster shows slight chatter on Liberty's cheek that limits the grade. The obverse has a lovely tint of champagne over the semi-reflective fields while the reverse delivers stark black-on-white contrast for a dazzling cartwheel effect. The overall quality and eye appeal is strong and deserving of the Plus-grade from PCGS and endorsement from CAC.
Ex: Global Showcase (Stack's Bowers, 8/2024), lot 3231. (PCGS# 7190)
Auction 63334 | Lot: 92048 | Aug 25, 2025

Sold For: $48,000.00

Make Offer to Owner
$72,000 or more
1901 $1 MS64 PCGS. Only a trace of pale champagne toning is present on each side of this satiny near-Gem. It is a sharply struck piece with excellent detail on both sides. The typical 1901 has unusual texturing on the reverse, caused by abnormal metal flow that resulted from improper striking pressure. Seen on some other dates, the resulting rippled surfaces are more pronounced on this date than any other in the series. Collectors are advised to seek an example such as this piece, where the unusual textured appearance is minimal.

For the serious collector of Morgan dollars, this date is one of the biggest challenges in the series, and is usually found in circulated or low-end Mint State grades. Choice and Gem pieces are extremely rare. Like certain other dates, nearly all of the production of 1901 Morgan dollars was placed in circulation. Even AU coins are common, although a shortage of true Mint State pieces keeps the price of AU coins at strong levels. For the connoisseur, Choice and Gem pieces appear on the market infrequently, but are well worth the wait.

1901 was a transitional year at the Philadelphia Mint. The new Spring Garden Street facility was occupied in June, and ready to begin coinage production in October. It seems that nearly the entire Morgan dollar production was accomplished at the old facility on Chestnut Street. Official Mint records indicate that 6,842,000 coins were produced from January through September, and only 120,000 during the remaining three months at the new Mint building. Population: 20 in 64, 3 finer (2/07).
From The Jackson Hole Collection. (PCGS# 7272)
Auction 450 | Lot: 103 | Apr 10, 2007

Sold For: $37,375.00
1858 1C Small Letters PR65 PCGS. Low Leaves Reverse. PR-2. This is one of the finest known examples of this rare issue, and it is also one of the most aesthetically desirable. A stunning specimen, Richard Snow describes it as a "deep mirror cameo Gem." The devices are fully struck up with every feather and wreath element showing razor sharp detail. The fields are virtually flawless and show splendid mirrored reflectivity when held at direct angles. Characteristic striations (as produced) are also evident when the coin rotates under the light, and they are suggestive of a very early die state. Aside from the outstanding condition of this piece, the eye appeal benefits from beautiful champagne, apricot, and pastel-lilac shadings. A few well scattered and not outwardly distracting carbon flecks are noted for accuracy, although we stress that they are barely perceptible to the naked eye.

The mintage of 200 pieces that many catalogers report for this proof issue seems to be somewhat higher than the actual number of coins produced. A more appropriate estimate would be somewhere in the range of 100 pieces. There is also some confusion surrounding the number of coins extant, particularly because auction records include prooflike business strikes that the Mint issued in the 1858 12-piece pattern sets. These coins are still occasionally graded as proofs in error. Furthermore, the errors in the PCGS Population Report described for the proof 1858 Large Letters Cent also make it difficult to ascertain the number of survivors for the present issue. Nevertheless, Richard Snow believes that approximately 75 proof 1858 Small Letters Flying Eagle Cents are extant, a total that makes this issue similar in overall rarity to the proof 1857.

Collectors with enough curiosity to look at the reverses of their coins may discover the changes that the Mint implemented in 1858. At some time early in the year the design was changed in an effort to lower the relief. This would enable the coiner to les (PCGS# 2043)
Auction 308 | Lot: 4411 | Jan 11, 2003

Sold For: $36,800.00
Newfoundland, 1870 50 Cent Plain Edge SPECIMEN 66 PCGS. Champagne and gold toning with hints of blue, a razor sharp strike, and no significant flaws. Newfoundland 50 Cent coins in proof are very rare and desirable issues. If you have the opportunity, you should try to view these coins, as there may never be another group of Specimen 50 Cents to equal the ones in this collection. This coin is one of 3 certified by PCGS and it is, by far, the finest of the three. 1870 is the first year that Newfoundland 50 Cent coins were struck, and one might expect production of a sizeable number of Specimens. That is not the case, as the total number of Plain Edge 50 Cents is probably no more than 6-7, and some of these are in permanent collections. (PCGS# 33246)
Auction 312 | Lot: 15767 | Jan 13, 2003

Sold For: $34,500.00
1916 5C PR68 PCGS. The final year of issue for the matte proof Buffalo Nickel series. In terms of technical preservation as well as aesthetic appeal, this is one of the finest matte proof Nickels we have ever handled. The surfaces are carbon-free and there are no visible contact marks on either side. The only identifier is a microscopic black speck that rests in the right obverse field near the Indian's upper lip. Both sides initially present as brilliant, but a hint of sky-blue and champagne patina is seen as the coin is turned under a light. Anyone considering assembling a set of matte proofs owes it to themselves to at least view this coin. Population: 7 in 68, none are finer (10/05). (PCGS# 3993)
Auction 388 | Lot: 2048 | Nov 5, 2005

Sold For: $27,600.00
1917-S 50C Obverse MS65 PCGS. When the first Walkers were coined in 1916, the branch mint issues had their mintmarks on the obverse, just below the motto IN GOD WE TRUST. This trend continued into the first weeks of 1917. The mintmark was moved to the reverse in February of that year. In The Complete Guide to Walking Liberty Half Dollars, Bruce Fox recorded the reason: "On February 14, 1917, mint director F.J.H. von Engelken verbally ordered the change of mintmark location from the obverse to the reverse. The reason being 'the obverse mintmark had the appearance of a defect in the die and was entirely too prominent.' In April, the Philadelphia mint superintendent Adam M. Joyce wrote the new mint director, Raymond T. Baker, for a written confirmation of the order verbally given in February. On April 14, 1917, Baker issued the order in writing." This example is a splendid Gem with pale champagne toning over frosty luster. The design details are quite sharp for this early issue. This is nearly the finest available quality, as indicated by the PCGS population data. Population: 30 in 65, 3 finer (9/04). (PCGS# 6572)
Auction 358 | Lot: 6880 | Nov 6, 2004

Sold For: $27,600.00
1858 1C Small Letters PR66 Cameo NGC. Low Leaves Reverse. Snow-PR-2. This is one of the finest known examples of this rare issue, and it is also one of the most aesthetically desirable. A stunning specimen, the devices are fully struck up with every feather and wreath element showing razor sharp detail. The fields are virtually flawless and show splendid mirrored reflectivity when held at direct angles. Characteristic striations are also evident when the coin rotates under the light, and they are suggestive of a very early die state. Aside from the outstanding condition of this piece, the eye appeal benefits from beautiful champagne, apricot, and pastel-lilac shadings. A small diagonal abrasion is noted above the 185 of the date, this being mentioned solely for future identification purposes.

The mintage of 200 pieces that many catalogers report for this proof issue seems to be somewhat higher than the actual number of coins produced. A more appropriate estimate would be somewhere in the range of 100 pieces. There is also some confusion surrounding the number of coins extant, particularly because auction records include prooflike business strikes that the mint issued in the 1858 12-piece pattern sets. These coins are still occasionally graded as proofs in error. Richard Snow believes that approximately 75 proof 1858 Small Letters Flying Eagle Cents are extant, a total that makes this issue similar in overall rarity to the proof 1857.

Collectors with enough curiosity to look at the reverses of their coins may discover the changes that the Mint implemented in 1858. At some time early in the year the design was changed in an effort to lower the relief. This would enable the coiner to lessen the striking pressure and extend working die life. The high relief design is called the "High Leaves Reverse" because the leaves inside the wreath at the C and T in CENT are fairly long. This design was in use in 1856, 1857, and early 1858 and may also be called the "Type of 1857." The l (PCGS# 2043)
Auction 349 | Lot: 6016 | Jun 5, 2004

Sold For: $27,499.95
1913-S 5C Type Two MS67 NGC. James Earle Fraser made his only contribution to America's circulating coinage in 1913, when his Buffalo nickel design made its debut. Once the pieces made their way to circulation, Fraser's inclinations as a sculptor and a medalist ran afoul of coinage needs: the denomination FIVE CENTS, raised on a mound at the lower reverse, were prone to wearing away. The Mint moved to redesign the pieces, and the bison stood on flat ground for the new Type Two nickels, which made their debut late in the same year.

This is a simply stunning example of the 1913-S Type Two nickel, widely known as one of the most elusive Buffalo nickels, particularly in high grades. The strike is considerably above-average, particularly on the Indian's braid, and the fields exhibit wonderful luster with a thin veneer of champagne patina. Hardly any marks appear on the surfaces of this elite survivor. Census: 4 in 67, 0 finer (4/07). (PCGS# 3923)
Auction 438 | Lot: 484 | Jun 2, 2007

Sold For: $23,000.00
1858 50C PR65 Cameo NGC. Although this year marked the beginning of a regular program to make Proof coins available to collectors, essentially marking the start of active numismatic happenings in this country, sales were slim during the year, and today few Proofs survive. The historically reported mintage figure of 80 coins dates from the Chapman Brothers, who suggested that number were struck. It is possible that they were reporting an figure from some earlier numismatist. Today, however, it is conceded that the actual "true" mintage is in the neighborhood of 300 coins. Even this figure is subject to discussion. To date, PCGS and NGC have combined to certify 115 examples of this date, with just five of those certified as Cameo Proofs. It is not known what percentage of this total includes resubmissions, however, we believe that not more than about 50 different examples survive.

That offered in this lot has exceptional contrast with fully lustrous devices and nicely mirrored fields. The center of each side is essentially brilliant with just a wisp of champagne color, surrounded by deeper gold, lilac, and blue toning. The surfaces have a few minor lint marks and other blemishes, but only a single raised bubble in the field below the inside base of the final A serves to mark the pedigree. This is the finest certified Cameo Proof example of the date, and may represent one of the most appealing examples regardless of designation. Population: 1 in 65 Cameo, 0 finer (8/05).
From The Ken Arnold Collection. (PCGS# 86412)
Auction 384 | Lot: 3269 | Sep 24, 2005

Sold For: $20,700.00
1796 $1 Small Date, Large Letters AU50 PCGS. B-4, BB-61, R.2. Die State I per the Bowers-Borckardt reference. The top curl is intact without any evidence of die lapping. Most examples of the B-4 variety are in this early die state. Similar die state to lot 23487 in the Reiver sale. Although this is the most common variety of the year, as evidenced by three examples in the present sale, it is seldom encountered in the finer grades. A few splendid Mint State examples are known, followed by these three coins and a small number of other really attractive AU pieces. The typical survivor is apt to grade VF or so. This is a lovely AU grade coin with light silver-gray color accented by pale champagne and light gold toning. The surfaces retain considerable luster, especially on the reverse.
From The Royal Oak Collection. (PCGS# 6860)
Auction 414 | Lot: 5286 | Aug 14, 2006

Sold For: $18,400.00
1857 $1 PR64 NGC. There are apparently two different die varieties known for the Proof Seated Dollars of this year, although this is another issue that needs considerable additional study. An unfinished area of the die below Liberty's chin has sometimes been called a beard. In the date, the left edge of the base of the 1 is over the left half of a dentil below. The shield point is over the left edge of the upright of this digit, or perhaps ever so slightly right of it. Apparently, the sharply defined head of Liberty is also a characteristic of this first variety. The obverse die of the second variety is quite similar, but reportedly always with the head of Liberty flat, much like the typical business strikes of this date. It may be this last feature that is the only distinguishing characteristic in older catalog photos. The reverse from each of these varieties is apparently different, and these two reverses are also quite similar. It may actually be determined that these two reverse dies are actually one and the same.

This example is sharply struck with a full head. It has exceptional aesthetic appeal, with only the faintest traces of light champagne color on both sides. A rare issue with relatively few survivors, and the last issue before active sales of Proof coinage began for collectors. Population: 9 in 64, 6 finer (10/05).
From The Jack Lee Collection, III (PCGS# 7000)
Auction 388 | Lot: 2244 | Nov 5, 2005

Sold For: $17,250.00
1811/09 10C MS65 NGC. JR-1, R.3. This is a stunning Gem example of the overdate dime variety that represents the only die combination for the year. Both sides have pleasing pearl-gray color with hints of champagne toning on the reverse. The obverse exhibits frosty luster and the reverse displays satiny luster. This is a late die state with the usually seen die bulge above the Liberty cap, in addition to clash marks in the obverse fields. The reverse die is shattered with numerous die cracks, mostly radial, or extending from the border toward the center. Census: 6 in 65, 1 finer (10/06). (PCGS# 4487)
Auction 420 | Lot: 492 | Nov 30, 2006

Sold For: $17,250.00
1855 $1 PR 63 PCGS. The business strike 1855 Seated dollar was produced to the extent of only 26,000 pieces, and, since most examples were exported and subsequently melted, coins of this date seldom appear on the market at any level of preservation. The proof 1855 Seated dollar is even rarer, and examples are offered less frequently then the already elusive proof 1854. Bowers (1993) asserts that 30-40 1855 silver dollars were included in the Mint's proof sets of this year. Several other examples were sold individually, perhaps bringing the total number of coins distributed to 75 pieces. If this number is accurate, than many of these coins have been subsequently lost, since NGC and PCGS combined have seen only 22 examples (resubmissions?) in grades that range from PR 61 through PR 65.

An obviously important coin for Seated dollar specialists, the present example displays a uniformly reflective finish beneath smoky champagne and golden-gray iridescence. The strike is nearly full, being kept from that status by a little bluntness of definition over the top of the eagle's left (facing) wing. A pinscratch in the right obverse field, as well as a few areas of porosity in the same field, are noted for accuracy. (PCGS# 6998)
Auction 257 | Lot: 628 | Apr 7, 2001

Sold For: $14,375.00
1857 1C PR64 Cameo PCGS. This is a rare issue, and the present specimen is of further importance because it is only the second proof 1857 Flying Eagle Cent to receive a Cameo designation at PCGS (9/03). We auctioned the first, a Proof 63 Cameo, about a year ago. The mirrored fields on this coin are about as deep and vibrant as one is likely to see on a specimen striking of this type. Furthermore, the devices are fully defined and the denticles crisp--features that further confirm this coin's status as a proof. There are a few wispy hairlines and scattered contact marks on both sides along with remnants of a fingerprint and some carbon spotting on the reverse. A scintillating, reddish-gold representative with suggestions of champagne and gray tinting on the reverse. (PCGS# 82040)
Auction 334 | Lot: 5131 | Nov 10, 2003

Sold For: $13,800.00
1855 $1 PR63 PCGS. Formerly sold in our 2001 Central States Bullet Sale, where it was described as, "The business strike 1855 Seated dollar was produced to the extent of only 26,000 pieces, and, since most examples were exported and subsequently melted, coins of this date seldom appear on the market at any level of preservation. The proof 1855 Seated dollar is even rarer, and examples are offered less frequently then the already elusive proof 1854. Bowers (1993) asserts that 30-40 1855 silver dollars were included in the Mint's proof sets of this year. Several other examples were sold individually, perhaps bringing the total number of coins distributed to 75 pieces. If this number is accurate, than many of these coins have been subsequently lost, since NGC and PCGS combined have seen only 22 examples (resubmissions?) in grades that range from PR61 through PR65.

An obviously important coin for Seated dollar specialists, the present example displays a uniformly reflective finish beneath smoky champagne and golden-gray iridescence. The strike is nearly full, being kept from that status by a little bluntness of definition over the top of the eagle's left (facing) wing. A pinscratch in the right obverse field, as well as a few areas of porosity in the same field, are noted for accuracy." (PCGS# 6998)
Auction 267 | Lot: 6503 | Aug 11, 2001

Sold For: $13,225.00
1866 50C PR68 NGC. The tremendous bloodletting of the Civil War sparked a religious revival in the United States that affected the design of the Seated Half Dollar in 1866. In that year, a scroll upon which the motto IN GOD WE TRUST is inscribed was added to the reverse field over the eagle. Those survivors of the 725-piece proof delivery abound in first-year type collections. However, there is only one collector who can display a certified PR68 representative of this important and popular issue, and he/she will be the winner of this lot. As befits a proof Seated coin from the Kaufman Collection, this Superb Gem possesses colorful, attractive toning. Indirect angles display olive-charcoal patina that lightens to silver-gray (obverse) and apricot-gray (reverse) hues in the centers. It is at direct light angles, however, that this coin becomes truly attractive due to the emergence of overlapping swirls of champagne, gold, blue, green, and salmon-pink iridescence. Every feature is equally full in terms of striking definition with nary a grade-limiting blemish to report. One of several finest known proof Seated coins that we have the privilege of offering in this sale.
Ex: Orlando Sale (Superior, 8/1992), lot 317.
From the Philip Kaufman Collection. (PCGS# 6424)
Auction 318 | Lot: 6783 | May 3, 2003

Sold For: $12,650.00
1916-S 50C MS66 NGC. The 1916-S is by far the scarcest of the first-year Walking Liberty issues at all grade levels and can only occasionally be located in the lower reaches of Mint State. This incredible example is among the nicest we have recently seen of the first year key. Both obverse and reverse exhibit a bright, satiny sheen that is hardly disturbed by coin-to-coin contact and central striking details that are quite bold for the issue. A light coating of champagne toning frames the obverse and most of the reverse. It is very nearly a full strike with excellent detail on both sides. Bruce Fox discussed the value of such a sharply struck coin: "Coins that are nicely struck with minimal abrasions commonly sell at or above Coin Dealer Newsletter bid prices at auction." We certainly expect this example to sell for considerably more than the bid price. The prospective bidder will certainly want to prepare accordingly. Population: 10 in 66, 1 finer (6/05).
From The Robert Moreno Collection. (PCGS# 6568)
Auction 382 | Lot: 10003 | Jul 30, 2005

Sold For: $12,650.00
1879 50C PR68 NGC. In order for the operational mints to conform to the terms of the Bland-Allison Act of 1878, production of the other silver denominations had to take a back seat to the Morgan Dollar. For the Seated Half this meant an era of limited Philadelphia Mint deliveries that spanned from 1879 through the end of the series in 1891. The former year witnessed the production of only 4,800 business strikes and 1,100 proofs. Catalogers and other numismatists who overstate the rarity of these deliveries seem to forget that the limited mintage figures were recognized at the time of delivery. As such, many examples were set aside for posterity. On the other hand, few that were have survived with truly pristine, gorgeously toned surfaces. In the case of the specimen strikings, the present example is the only one graded PR68 at NGC and PCGS (none are finer, 1/03). The obverse is drenched in antique-copper color that yields to a virtually brilliant, lilac and champagne ringed center. A blush of salmon-pink over the eagle's left (facing) wing along with blushes of golden-champagne iridescence at the upper right border interrupt the otherwise antique-copper appearance of the reverse. The often seen iridescent undertones are evident at direct angles, as well as fully brilliant proof qualities. A fully brought up Superb Gem for the specialist who desires the utmost in quality for their collection.
Ex: Orlando Sale (Superior, 8/1992), lot 417.
From the Philip Kaufman Collection. (PCGS# 6440)
Auction 318 | Lot: 6790 | May 3, 2003

Sold For: $12,075.00
1797 $1 9x7 Stars, Large Letters AU50 NGC. B-1, BB-73, R.3. Die State II. Reiver State a. Seven stars right; leaf tip at center of M. An early die state before either die developed cracks. The point of the hair curl is missing from light die lapping. Pleasing champagne and gray color on each side with considerable remaining luster. A few tiny surface ticks are evident on each side. Aside from 1794 with but a single variety, fewer varieties were produced with the 1797 date than for any other early silver dollar issue. Each of the three known varieties is plentiful enough to be obtainable, and each represents a specific different subtype within the series of Small Eagle dollars coined from 1795 to 1798. Approximately 1,500 silver dollars dated 1797 survive today from an unknown original mintage. Mint records indicate a total production of just 7,776 silver dollars during the year, but it is now believed that most or all were actually coins bearing the 1796 date. The production of silver dollars dated 1797 probably actually took place in 1798.
Ex: Tom Eckert (5/2001).
From The William Luebke Collection. (PCGS# 6863)
Auction 422 | Lot: 4964 | Jan 6, 2007

Sold For: $12,075.00
1892 $1 PR67 PCGS. With Charles Barber's Dime, Quarter, and Half Dollar making their debut this year, the Mint felt required to prepare an abnormally large number of proof sets for sale to collectors. The mintage of the 1892 Silver Dollar (like that of the other silver denominations) amounted to 1,245 specimens. Nevertheless, the 1892 does not appear to be appreciably more common than most of the other issues in the proof Morgan Dollar series. Perhaps (as Bowers, 1993, states) a decent number of proofs from this year were placed into circulation.

One would be hard pressed to find a proof 1892 Silver Dollar at this grade level that could match or surpass the eye appeal of this coin. Multilayered antique-copper, salmon-pink, lavender, and champagne toning surrounds areas of virtual brilliance in the centers. The color is a little more extensive on the reverse, both sides being equally as well preserved with no distracting blemishes to report. Fully impressed with shimmering, glassy fields. Population: 17 in 67, with a mere two finer.
From the Bay Area Collection. (PCGS# 7327)
Auction 316 | Lot: 6783 | Mar 23, 2003

Sold For: $11,500.00
1935 $1 MS67 NGC. This example is tied with three others for finest certified honors at NGC. The rival grading service, PCGS, has never certified an example of this date at the Superb Gem MS67 grade level. The mintage of 1,576,000 coins in this final year was the eighth lowest of any issue during the series, from 1921 through 1935. A remarkable Superb Gem example with sharp design features on both sides and with exceptional satiny white luster. Aside from the slightest veil of champagne toning, the surfaces are fully brilliant.
From The Robert Moreno Registry Collection of Peace Dollars. (PCGS# 7378)
Auction 402 | Lot: 1234 | Apr 7, 2006

Sold For: $10,350.00
1858 $1 PR64 NGC. As the sole proof-only issue in the Seated Dollar series, the 1858 is an immensely popular coin among specialists. It is also a rare coin, although we do not know exactly how many pieces were made because the Mint did not start keeping proof mintage records until the following year. Estimates have ranged from as low as 80 coins (per S. Hudson and Henry Chapman) to as high as 600 coins extant (per the Gobrecht Journal, July 1982). All we can do with certainty is quote combined NGC and PCGS population data, which lists 111 coins in all grades, 14 examples of which are impaired (1/02). Of course, some of these "coins" are probably resubmissions of the same specimens.

This is an aesthetically pleasing near-Gem with bright surfaces and delicate champagne iridescence that seems to gravitate toward the borders. There is a little light golden color on the obverse around the Liberty cap, and a small, inconspicuous toning spot outside that device is noted. The uniformly reflective features are expectantly distraction-free for the Choice level of preservation. Pedigree concerns compel us to mention an area of planchet porosity (as produced) on the obverse within the lower loop of the first 8 in the date, and a trio of circular planchet voids (also as struck) in the reverse field between the top of the eagle's right (facing) wing and the ME in AMERICA.

The Mint used only one obverse die to produce this issue. Two reverse dies are known, one of which was used to produce some proof 1856 and 1857 Seated Dollars, the other of which was used to produce some proof 1859 examples. With rust lumps over the lower left base of the L in DOL and on the rim below the base of that letter, the present near-Gem was struck from the former die. A late die state with an additional rust lump over the upper left corner of the D in DOL, this coin was probably struck at the same time as the Silverman proof 1856 example, both of which were delivered after the proof 1857 specimen (PCGS# 7001)
Auction 288 | Lot: 4086 | Apr 27, 2002

Sold For: $10,350.00
1859 1C PR66 NGC. Broad borders, razor sharp striking detail, and glowing reflectivity in the fields readily identify this coin as a proof. There is also a reverse die chip (as produced) between the denticles just before 12 o'clock that is diagnostic of the reverse die used for the proof 1859 Indian Cent. The otherwise honey-tan color yields to pastel tinged champagne, apricot, and lilac shadings as the surfaces dip into the light. Striations (also as struck) are seen at the same angles, but there are expectantly few blemishes for the premium quality Gem grade. Although federal records report that 800 proofs were made in this, the first year of the Indian Cent series, many examples were melted as unsold at year's end. A rare date, survivors are always in demand for first-year proof type purposes.
From the Joseph P. Gorrell Collection. (PCGS# 2247)
Auction 388 | Lot: 239 | Nov 5, 2005

Sold For: $7,475.00
1865 3CN PR 66 PCGS. The business strike and proof 1865 three cent nickels sit at opposite ends of the rarity scale. The former issue is the most common in this series, the latter is the key date, and it is more difficult to find choice than the proof-only 1877. This is the first Gem proof 1865 three cent nickel that we have offered in more than a year. There is a modest cameo contrast on the obverse, the reverse is somewhat more uniform in finish. A thin veil of champagne iridescence dances across the bright, distraction-free surfaces. This coin is sure to elicit strong bids from advanced specialists. (PCGS# 3761)
Auction 257 | Lot: 216 | Apr 7, 2001

Sold For: $7,360.00
1873-CC 50C No Arrows MS61 PCGS. All 122,500 1873-CC No Arrows Half Dollars were produced from one of two obverse dies, both of which are of the Closed 3 variety. The Carson City Mint used only one reverse die for this delivery, and the mintmark is small. This is a scarce coin in all grades, due, no doubt, to extensive melting at the Mint. Most examples that managed to leave the Mint entered circulation, where they acquired varying degrees of wear. This is the first Mint State representative that we have offered this year, and it is a mostly untoned, silver-gray example. A few swirls of champagne and golden iridescence are, however, seen around the rims. There are no large or objectionable abrasions, and the strike is bold in all areas save for over Liberty's head. Muted luster accounts for the grade. Population: 1 in 61, 7 finer (8/01). (PCGS# 6338)
Auction 271 | Lot: 6994 | Oct 6, 2001

Sold For: $7,130.00
1866 25C Motto MS65 PCGS. This a stunning Gem that is among the finest known pieces of this first-year of issue type coin. The mintage of this date was just 16,800 business strikes and another 725 proofs. Although Walter Breen reported that many Mint State examples were recovered from proof sets of the year, we doubt that the quantity was all that high. This example is fully brilliant with a hint of champagne toning. The fields are reflective, with fully lustrous devices and excellent cameo contrast. Noticeable weakness of the designs at the center of the obverse and reverse is diagnostic for the issue, and is used to distinguish business strikes from proofs. Population: 2 in 65, 1 finer (10/06).
From The Park Cities Collection. (PCGS# 5468)
Auction 420 | Lot: 634 | Nov 30, 2006

Sold For: $6,900.00
1859 1C PR66 NGC. Broad borders, razor sharp striking detail, and glowing reflectivity in the fields readily identify this coin as a proof. There is also a reverse die chip (as produced) between the denticles just before 12 o'clock that is diagnostic of the reverse die used for the proof 1859 Indian Cent. The otherwise honey-tan color yields to pastel tinged champagne, apricot, and lilac shadings as the surfaces dip into the light. Striations (also as struck) are seen at the same angles, but there are expectantly few blemishes for the premium quality Gem grade. Although federal records report that 800 proofs were made in this, the first year of the Indian Cent series, many examples were melted as unsold at year's end. A rare date, survivors are always in demand for first-year proof type purposes.
From the Joseph P. Gorrell Collection. (PCGS# 2247)
Auction 308 | Lot: 4472 | Jan 11, 2003

Sold For: $6,900.00
1893-CC $1 MS62 PCGS. The final year of silver dollar coinage at Carson City amounted to 677,000 pieces struck, many of which went into circulation while large quantities went into vault storage. However, those pieces in vault storage were either melted after the 1918 Pittman Act or were distributed to casinos in the years following, as by the time of the GSA sales in the 1970s, only a single coin remained in government control. This Mint State example displays frosty brilliant mint luster with a hint of peripheral champagne. Moderate central strike softness is as usual for the date, although scattered abrasions are minor for the MS62 grade. (PCGS# 7222)
Auction 60481 | Lot: 52232 | Sep 22, 2025

Sold For: $6,900.00
1802 $1 Narrow Date AU53 NGC. B-5, BB-242, High R.5. Die State I. Perfect T; projection at lower right curve of D. This is a rare and often overlooked die marriage that is mostly populated by VF to XF examples and has perhaps fewer than 50 pieces extant in all grades. In practice, this variety is easily recognized by the perfect T in LIBERTY, the only 1802 Normal Date variety with this characteristic. It is the rarest Normal Date variety and the second rarest variety of the year. This lustrous AU representative has light silver-gray surfaces with hints of champagne toning on each side. Considerable luster is evident. Both sides have scattered surface marks and faint hairlines. Although a few finer examples are known, this piece is almost certainly in the Condition Census for the variety.
Ex: Heritage (5/2003), lot 6463.
From The William Luebke Collection. (PCGS# 6896)
Auction 422 | Lot: 5045 | Jan 6, 2007

Sold For: $6,900.00

1

2 3 4 5 6

Results per page: 24 48 72